Thèse soutenue

Droit, gouvernance d'entreprise et structure du système financier : analyse économétrique du cas français

FR  |  
EN
Auteur / Autrice : Afef Boughanmi
Direction : Bruno Deffains
Type : Thèse de doctorat
Discipline(s) : Sciences économiques
Date : Soutenance le 25/06/2007
Etablissement(s) : Nancy 2
Ecole(s) doctorale(s) : École doctorale SJPEG - Sciences Juridiques, Politiques, Economiques et de Gestion (Lorraine)
Jury : Examinateurs / Examinatrices : Mireille Jaeger, Dorothée Rivaud-Danset
Rapporteurs / Rapporteuses : Michel Boutillier, Régis Blazy

Résumé

FR  |  
EN

The World Bank reports "Doing business" (2004, 2005 and 2006), referring to the main assumptions and findings of the "law and finance" theory, predict that the common law system provides better for financial development and economic growth than French origin civil law. This thesis challenges the "law and finance" theory supported by La Porta, Lopez-de-Silanes, Shleifer and Vishny (LLSV). Thus, it undergoes an empirical investigation of the role of corporate governance in financial development and in shaping the financial structure of firms. We focus on French corporate governance reforms in order to examine whether these reforms are consistent with a reorganization of the French financial system during the period 1980-2004. This research aims to evaluate the proposition that there is a strong and stable relationship between legal origin, investor protection and financial system. LLSV affirm, in addition, that the causality is from law to finance. Our analysis considers the dynamic aspect of corporate governance. The key question the study suggests that indicators of investor protection may be independent from legal origin. In addition, our investigation is rather focuses on other stakeholders (employees and bondholders) and points out that the stakeholder' point of view appears to be more relevant, than the shareholder approach, to understand the corporate governance mechanisms. Our econometric investigation is rather new as the law and finance literature has not always focused on the elaboration of corporate governance indicators suitable for the french legislation. Also, our thesis undergoes a multiple criteria analysis of corporate governance reforms, which is a method not yet used in the growing literature generated by the legal corporate governance approach. Indeed, we weight the dummy variables according to the importance of stakeholder rights included in the constructions of the indicators. This methodology shows that the causality is especially from finance to law. This thesis yields results that mitigate the main LLSV's predictions and emphasize the merits of the stakeholder approach.